And here I thought weight was good -- although I use aluminum or steel -- whatever's available. Steel costs less, if I remember right, and wear and rust aren't a problem. I clean the system after runs and the event.
And since I've got lead in the back area of the bike for ballast -- improves traction, you've heard this before -- what's an extra pound (steel vs. Al)? Yeah, I know, sprung vs. unsprung -- but still, I'm not running Laguna Seca, so no big deal. If the extra weight of steel reduces the ability of the rear wheel to spin up quickly -- hey, that's a good thing, not a bad thing. I've got at least ninety seconds -- take my time, don't spin that back wheel.
I vote steel unless they only make that tooth count in Aluminum, but it doesn't really matter that much.