1/4" 5052... It's about the only one you can bend without it cracking or breaking. I'll build stops on both of those pedals so I don't kill them by pushing down too hard. It takes quite a bit to bend it, but it does very nicely.
Thanks. I did a little research on the alloys of Aluminum and found a good summary on MetalsOnline.com. The 5052 they sell is H32 treated which is "Strain hardened and stabilized by low temperature heating to 1/4 hard" It has a yield strength of about 28,000 psi compared to 6061-T6, which has a yield strength of about 40,000 psi. I know that 6061-T6 can be cold bent carefully around a radius, but not sharply. I have successfully bent 1/8" thick flat bar around a 1" diameter mandrel, and 1/4" around a 4" mandrel, but trying to bend it sharply, as in a vise, will crack or break it. It can be annealed (I said "normalized" in my above question, but that apparently only applies to carbon steel) by heating to the correct temperature, even after cooling, for bending more sharply. I believe it will air harden in time, but I'm not sure if it will attain the same strength.
I had not tried 5052, but you have shown it can be bent more easily than the more common 6061. The article also mentioned that 6061 can be annodized, but it didn't mention annodizing 5052.